Ugh. I started off liking Anoop but my real favourite this season was Matt, but only because of his iTunes studio recordings of his performances each week. His voice is
exactly the type of male voice I like listening to. It's like a more vocally agile Justin Timberlake with a greater singing focus in his songs. I downloaded his 2 pre-Idol albums but they're largely too amateur for me to enjoy. A few songs are nice, like "How" and "Could You Use a Love", but his AI recordings are several notches up in both the vocal department and production value. And yet they're still largely tacky covers of other people's songs. I really feel that he can be successful if he gets the right people behind him to help him write, produce and market the music that would best suit his considerable strengths. The talent is certainly there. The voice is there, and probably could do with even more improvement and strenghtening, especially in the upper range, if it were to be really spectacular. His riffs are like nothing else. He has a really gorgeous sense of groove to his voice with a really strong and modern pop/r&b sensibility, but grounded in natural technique. Just listen to his "come on, come on, come on" part in "Let's Get It On" or the smoothness and integration of his runs in "Part-Time Lover". His "Who's Lovin' You" is probably my favourite live performance on Idol this season from any contestant. He just has a really nice tone, really good vocal control, and the requisite passion and expertise. I'm kind of bummed he was eliminated even though it was overwhelmingly predicted. I really just wanted him to stay until Top 3 or something so I could have enough studio recordings of his to form an "album".
As for Anoop, he's probably still my sentimental favourite. I like Matt because I like what he offers. I like Anoop more on an emotional/personal level. He just seems like a really intelligent, well-spoken guy with an unexpectedly soulful voice. My problem with Anoop was I felt he essentially regressed throughout the competition. He started off the best with "Angel of Mine" and "My Prerogative", but then subsequent weeks he just delivered the same old, same old. I think he probably just lost confidence among his competitors and lost his sense of self. His relative lack of musical experience (not just in solo performance, but in arrangements, production, recording etc.) probably also disadvantaged him, particularly as he doesn't have an absolutely stand-out voice, but rather just a competent voice with a really nice smooth/r&b tone. He needed to take more risks, to go for more glory notes, to go for more riffs and runs, to go for more inspired song choices. I just became frustrated with him because I felt he had more to offer than what he was presenting. Then I think, maybe I really just liked him with the Clef Hangers? Maybe he performs best in the setting he's used to, among his friends in that group, where he is clearly the stand-out and can comfortably and confidently shine. But then I listen to "
Angel" and I'm just confused ... why didn't he sing like that, or a song like that, on Idol? I listen to his performance of "
The Only One For Me", or "
I'll Make Love to You" and it's just like, wtffff. For me, while the setting is of course different, those performances are so infinitely superior to anything he ever did on Idol,
possibly "Always on my Mind" excepting. Oh well, I think this season sucks. The glory days are over for Idol, but I still love the show for what it brings. I think entertainment still needs and craves American Idol.